Taking the MyCAREER journey through MLB The Show 25 also raises a different question: which teams feature the highest-rated shortstops in the league? Joining a team with elite shortstop talent gives a mlb 25 stubs guidedifferent kind of challenge—trying to learn from or compete against the best of the best.

At the top of the list is the Kansas City Royals with Bobby Witt Jr., an astonishing 96 overall. His speed, power, and defensive ability make him arguably the best shortstop in the game. Being on his team as a shortstop means you're substituting or outperforming one of the best. That’s a steep hill, but mastering your own MyPLAYER to either take starting reps or prove your worth in other ways can become a defining challenge. If you’re into outplaying a silent legend, this is as big as it gets.

The New York Mets field Francisco Lindor, rated at 95. He is a superstar both visually and statistically, with the history and excitement that comes with the spotlight. Joining the Mets means competing for attention and playing time behind a high-profile shortstop, but the rewards and stage you get are worth it if you’re up to the chase. It’s competition that pushes you to elevate every facet of your game.

The Baltimore Orioles equip Gunnar Henderson at 94. He's young, explosive, and presents a prime opportunity for a developmental head-to-head. Competing with him means growing alongside a dynamic talent while carving out your own niche. It puts you in a band of rising stars under a club that fosters youth.

The Cincinnati Reds feature Elly De La Cruz at 93. His ratings reflect athleticism and a highlight reel stature. Game plays feel cinematic when you're up against De La Cruz. Try to match his hustle or even outshine him—playing time here becomes meaningful and dynamic.

The Texas Rangers own Corey Seager rated at 92, a proven winner with World Series pedigree. A legendary figure in MyCAREER context, being on Seager’s team —trying to become his understudy or successor—is a storyline loaded with potential. You learn from the best and build your own legacy.

Trea Turner of the Phillies comes in at 90. He represents consistency and speed, offering a balanced template. The Phillies offer a veteran shortstop where coming through the system could prove your worth as the next in line.

Beyond those ratings, watch for Carlos Correa, Dansby Swanson, Willy Adames, and Zach Neto with ratings in the mid 80s. Being in proximity to these players gives your player developmental goals—breaking into the lineup or timing your call-up when they shift.

Selecting a team with top-tier shortstop talent is about competition, motivation, and legacy. Whether you're trying to beat out Witt Jr., learn from Lindor, or take over for a superstar in decline, these clubs offer depth, challenge, and narrative.